yalealumnimagazine.com  
  1891  
spacer spacer spacer
 
rule
yalealumnimagazine.com   about the Yale Alumni Magazine   classified & display advertising   back issues 1992-present   our blogs   The Yale Classifieds   yam@yale.edu   support us

spacer
 

The Yale Alumni Magazine is owned and operated by Yale Alumni Publications, Inc., a nonprofit corporation independent of Yale University.

The content of the magazine and its website is the responsibility of the editors and does not necessarily reflect the views of Yale or its officers.

 

Comment on this article

In Print

Shepard Krech III '67
The Ecological Indian: Myth and History
W. W. Norton, $27.95

Among the indelible images of the early 1970s, one picture stands out: the Crying Indian. Ecological awareness was awakening in that decade, and an organization called Keep America Beautiful needed a surefire symbol for its antipollution campaign. The group found one in a Cherokee Indian named Iron Eyes Cody, and the posters, magazine ads, and television spots of the Native American shedding a tear over the sorry state of the environment touched the nation and helped change attitudes.

“Through the Crying Indian, Keep America Beautiful cleverly manipulated ideas deeply ingrained in the national consciousness,” writes Shepard Krech III '67, a professor of anthropology at Brown. The central idea is that “on matters involving the environment, [the Indian] is pure, and white people are polluting.”

This has long been the dominant image, but is it, in fact, correct? Were Native Americans exemplars of conservation, taking only what they needed and carefully preserving the natural landscape, or is this notion, however deeply held by whites and Indians alike, a Rousseau-esque fiction?

About 180 years ago, lawyer and amateur archeologist Henry M. Brackenridge cautioned that those “who look for primitive innocence and simplicity in what they call the state of nature” are “mistaken.” Krech, armed with an increasing amount of anthropological and archeological research, draws the same conclusion. The notion of the necessarily ecological Indian, he argues, “distorts culture,” “masks cultural diversity,” and, because it is seen as a “fundamental truth,” it deflects “any desire to fathom or confront the evidence for relationships between Indians and the environment.”

In examining such matters as the way various Indian tribes dug canals and used fire as land management tools and exploited buffalo, deer, beaver, and other animals, Krech shows that this relationship varied through time and place. California Indians, for example, regularly set the scrubby chaparral environment ablaze to “produce better forage for deer, increase yields of berries, ease the collection of seeds and bulbs, and suppress the destructive consequences of lightning-caused fires.” And yet, in other parts of the country, “the evidence that Indians lit fires that were then allowed to burn destructively and without regard to ecological consequences is abundant,” writes Krech.

The author demonstrates that conservation is surprisingly often not the proper word to describe how Native Americans used the large animals with whom they shared the continent. “Waste is ancient,” notes Krech, offering examples of buffalo killed well in excess of any tribal needs, and sometimes only for their tongues and humps, which were considered a delicacy. And though Indians certainly possessed an abundance of knowledge about the ecology and behavior of their prey, whatever religious beliefs they might have held about the natural world did not, in many cases, stop them from seeing animals as valuable commodities for trade and pursuing their quarry to, at times, local extinction.

“In recent years native people have not been of one mind on resource issues,” writes Krech. “They probably never have been.”

top

David Elliot Cohen '77
One Year Off: Leaving It All Behind for a Round-the-World Journey with Our Children
Simon and Schuster, $24

“Shortly after my fortieth birthday, I began to experience the first twinges of spiritual uneasiness,” writes David Cohen '77.

The author is hardly the first person to come face-to-face with a midlife crisis, and the idea of ditching one’s job and traveling the globe is not exactly an uncommon response to middle-aged ennui.

But Yale graduates are nothing if not creative. For example, when Chris Goodrich '78, '87MSL hit the midlife doldrums, he decided to hit the road in a sports car—one he built himself. And when Cohen felt that pressing need to find out what else life had to offer besides suburban satisfaction, he went off to roam the planet—but he took along his wife, Devi, and kids Kara, Willie, and Lucas, who were 8, 7, and 2 respectively when the journey began. This being the 1990s, he also took his laptop, on which he wrote nearly two-dozen progress reports that were distributed, by e-mail of course, to his followers.

The first of these dispatches, which began like a routine family newsletter, went out on December 15, 1995. “We recently decided to make some—how should we say it?—radical changes in our lifestyle,” Cohen wrote. “I know this is going to sound insane, but we’ve decided to sell our house, close down Cohen Publishers, Inc. [Cohen put together the best-selling A Day in the Life of America and similar coffee-table books], take the kids out of school, and travel internationally for a while.”

Precisely where they were going and for how long was up in the air, but that was fine by them, and, after a longer-than-anticipated disengagement process, the family left the U.S. in the beginning of August 1996. Their itinerary took them from Central America to Southeast Asia, from the Museum of Torture in Greece to the Great Barrier Reef in Australia, and is filled with both high and low adventures, travel tips—to thrill a 7-to-12 year old child, “nothing beats a wildlife safari,” but “leave your 3-year-old at home”—and revelations.

Lighting matches inside the Buddha caves of Pak Ou in Laos, Cohen was struck by a possible meaning to his journey: “To learn that we have only one pack of matches. To understand that we have to be in the best possible place when we light each one. To know that we must make each brief combustion a bright, shining moment that pierces the darkness and illuminates a thousand gods.”

top

Carmen L. Cozza, Special Assistant in Athletics, with Rick Odermatt
True Blue: The Carm Cozza Story
Yale University Press, $29.95

“I am convinced that in his own quiet way Carm Cozza is a genuine American hero,” says Rick Odermatt, a sportswriter for the New Haven Register, who teamed up to collaborate on the autobiography of the man whose football fortunes he covered for more than three decades. But while readers may find themselves quibbling with the Coach’s gridiron strategies, they are very likely to agree with Odermatt’s assessment.

Cozza begins his story by recounting perhaps the worst moment in recent Yale football history: The Tie, that ignominious game in November 1968 in which an undefeated Yale team journeyed to Cambridge and watched in horror as Harvard knotted the score at 29-29 in the last two minutes and 40 seconds. “When you are as heavily favored as we were., anything less than outright victory has the sting of a loss,” he wrote. “And believe me, I felt the sting as severely as anyone. I still feel it.”

But there are plenty of good memories to temper that bitter one, and football fans will find much to smile about as Cozza recounts a litany of great games and great players, among them Dick Jauron, John Pagliaro, Kevin Czinger, Rich Diana, and, of course, Calvin Hill and Brian Dowling.

This is a tale of a man who explains that “family is the strongest thing you can have in life, and… a football family is an extension of your real family.” In the finest coaching tradition, Cozza lived for his charges and did right by them, whatever the cost to his program’s national stature.

“Yale has a right to be proud of the extraordinarily high character, academic standing, and graduation rates among its athletes, and if we were left behind when other schools sacrificed their standards and invited excesses in the name of athletic excellence, so be it,” says Cozza. “Colleges should not be used as minor leagues for professional sports.”

But he is clearly saddened by his sport’s fall from the prominent position it once enjoyed—and could enjoy again. The coach calls for a modest program of merit scholarships for athletes. In the modern context of Yale and Ivy League athletics, this “sounds like heresy,” he admits. “But why should a small accommodation to competitive factors be viewed as anything other than a wise strategy to ensure success? I’ll tell you what heresy is—letting that magnificent football stadium behind the Walter Camp arch waste away three-quarters empty on Saturday afternoons … Yale football has too great a heritage, and is too important in the lives of hundreds of wonderful young men, to allow it to wallow in the mediocrity of recent years.”

back to top

Brief Reviews

Sylvia Brownrigg '86
The Metaphysical Touch
Farrar, Straus, and Giroux, $24
On the Internet, a “recovering” philosopher nicknamed Pi encounters JD, who is bent on suicide. The metaphysical sparks fly as both protagonists try to separate the real world from an imaginary one.

Dean Chadwin '86
Those Damn Yankees: The Secret Life of America’s Greatest Franchise
Verso, $25
In an irreverent look at the Yankees' record-breaking 1998 season, Chadwin finds evidence not of unprecedented excellence but rather of grotesquely unequal competition between the haves and have-nots.

Jesse Green '80
The Velveteen Father: An Unexpected Journey to Parenthood
Villard Books, $23.95
Just as a stuffed rabbit is made real by a child’s love, the author records the transformative effect that parenthood can have on people who least expect to become parents.

William J. Poorvu '56, with Jeffrey L. Cruikshank
The Real Estate Game: The Intelligent Guide to Decision-Making and Investment
Free Press, $28
A master investor and teacher explains the inner workings of the real-estate world through a series of profiles of the strategies of large- and small-scale players.

Richard A. Posner '59
An Affair of State: The Investigation, Impeachment, and Trial of President Clinton
Harvard University Press, $24.95
Federal Appeals Court justice Posner takes a balanced and scholarly look at the crisis that galvanized the nation and examines the lessons it offers to the body politic.

Ellen Lerner Rothman '94
White Coat: Becoming A Doctor at Harvard Medical School
William Morrow, $25
In the spirit of physician-writers Perri Klass and Richard Selzer, Rothman, now a pediatrician, recounts the despair and exhilaration in her journey from terrified novice to competent doctor.

back to top

More Books by Yale Authors

Tim Bachmeyer '64PhD and William A. Snyder
Preserving the Legacy of a Family-Owned Business: A Psychology of Business Succession and Estate Planning
Estate and Business Communications, Inc., $19.95

Eve Blau '78PhD
The Architecture of Red Vienna, 1919–1934
MIT Press, $60

Marshall Edelson, Professor Emeritus of Psychiatry, and David N. Berg '71, '72MA, Associate Clinical Professor of Psychiatry
Rediscovering Groups: A Psychoanalyst’s Journey Beyond Individual Psychology
Jessica Kingsley Publishers, $29.95

Eric Freeman '97PhD and Susanne Hupfer '96PhD, Fellows, Yale Center for Internet Studies
JavaSpaces Principles, Patterns, and Practice
Addison-Wesley, $39.95

Courtland W. Howland '79JD, Editor
Religious Fundamentalisms and the Human Rights of Women
St. Martin’s Press, $45

Jeff Humphries ’81PhD
Reading Emptiness: Buddhism and Literature
State University of New York Press, $16.95

Jonathan Hufstader ’60
Tongue of Water, Teeth of Stones: Northern Irish Poetry and Social Violence
University Press of Kentucky, $34.95

Christine Hunter ’74
Ranches, Rowhouses, and Railroad Flats—American Homes: How They Shape Our Landscapes and Neighborhoods
W.W. Norton, $29.95

Matthew Frye Jacobson, Associate Professor of American Studies and History
Whiteness of a Different Color: European Immigrants and the Alchemy of Race
Harvard University Press, $16.95

Arend Lijphart ’63PhD
Patterns of Democracy: Government Forms and Performance in Thirty-Six Countries
Yale University Press, $40

Fredrik Logevall ’93PhD
Choosing War: The Lost Chance for Peace and the Escalation of War in Vietnam
University of California Press, $35

Stephanie Merrim '78PhD
Early Modern Women’s Writing and Sor Juana Ines de la Cruz
Vanderbilt University Press, $47.95

Julie Mertus '88JD
Kosovo: How Myths and Truths Started a War
University of California Press, $55

Thomas L. Pangle '66 and Peter J. Ahrensdorf '80
Justice Among Nations: On the Moral Basis of Power and Peace
University Press of Kansas, $45

Helle Porsdam '87PhD
Legally Speaking: Contemporary American Culture and the Law
University of Massachusetts Press, $50

Robert F. Reid-Pharr ’89MA, ’91MA
Conjugal Union: The Body, the House, and the Black American
Oxford University Press, $35

W. William Reisman, McDougal Professor of Law
Law in Brief Encounters
Yale University Press, $27.50

Deborah L. Rhode ’74, ’77JD
Speaking of Sex: The Denial of Gender Equity
Harvard University Press, $17.95

Ralph Schmidt ’69, ’79MFS, Joyce Berry, and John Gordon, Pinchot Professor of Forestry
Forests to Fight Poverty: Creating National Strategies
Yale University Press, $30

Leon V. Sigal ’64
Disarming Strangers: Nuclear Diplomacy with North Korea
Princeton University Press, $16.95

L.A. Smolley ’72 and Debra Fulghum Bruce
The Snoring Cure: Simple Steps to Getting a Good Night’s Sleep
W.W. Norton, $23.95

William C. Summers, Professor of Therapeutic Radiology
Felix d'Herelle and the Origins of Molecular Biology
Yale University Press, $30

William Ury '75
Getting to Peace: Transforming Conflict at Home, at Work, and in the World
Penguin Putnam, Inc., $23.95

top

 
     
   
 
 
 
spacer
 

©1992–2012, Yale Alumni Publications, Inc. All rights reserved.

Yale Alumni Magazine, P.O. Box 1905, New Haven, CT 06509-1905, USA. yam@yale.edu